Locking vs Non-Locking Plates: What the Biomechanical Evidence Actually Supports
The argument is usually settled with the wrong evidence
Locking plates are standard in human trauma surgery and increasingly standard in veterinary orthopaedics. The commercial argument for them is usually made in one sentence: locking plates are stiffer and more stable. That sentence is true in the test conditions that have been published. It is also incomplete, because stiffness is only one of four variables that decide whether a construct works: stability, load sharing, biological cost and price.
Clinical disclaimer
Procedure choice is case-specific and must be made by the attending veterinary surgeon. This article summarizes published evidence and inventory implications; it is not an outcome guarantee and does not replace peer-reviewed literature, training courses or product instructions for use.
The published biomechanical literature is worth reading closely, including its limits.
What the finite element work shows
A finite element analysis in Veterinary World modelled a canine femur with a midshaft comminuted fracture and a 20 mm gap, then compared three constructs under physiological axial loading.
| Construct | Maximum implant stress | Proximal fragment displacement |
|---|---|---|
| Non-locking plate (stainless steel) | 1160.22 MPa | 2.37 mm |
| Double-rod clamp (stainless steel) | 628.34 MPa | 0.99 mm |
| Locking plate (titanium) | 446.63 MPa | 0.34 mm |
The non-locking construct carried the highest stress, exceeding the material's yield strength in the model, and displaced more than the clinically accepted limit for stable healing. The locking construct carried the lowest stress and displaced least.
Two caveats belong next to those numbers. First, this is a finite element model, not a clinical series: the result depends on assumed material properties, mesh quality and loading conditions. Second, the locking construct was modelled in titanium and the non-locking construct in stainless steel. Material and design are confounded, so the comparison cannot isolate the locking mechanism alone.
What the patellar fracture model adds
A 2025 Frontiers in Veterinary Science study compared pin and tension band wiring with two-hole and four-hole locking plates in a canine transverse patellar fracture model. Thirty 3D-printed models were built from CT data of a 45 kg Akita, ten per group, and tested in tension at a 135° stifle angle.
| Group | Result |
|---|---|
| Pin and tension band wiring | Progressive displacement; 342.7 ± 27.0 N at 3 mm displacement |
| Two-hole locking plate | Failure load 505.6 ± 66.6 N |
| Four-hole locking plate | Failure load 556.9 ± 39.6 N |
The locking groups were significantly stronger than the wiring group. There was no significant difference between the two-hole and four-hole plates, which supports the use of the smaller plate in small patients.
This is a synthetic model, not a clinical outcome study. It answers a mechanical question, not a healing question.
The long-term biological cost
A PLOS ONE study examined canine radii plated for 36 weeks and compared locking head screws with cortical screws used to compress the plate to the periosteum.
| Group | Bone mineral density before | After 36 weeks |
|---|---|---|
| Locking plate | 837.2 mg/cm3 | 804.7 mg/cm3 (not significant) |
| Compression plate | 834.3 mg/cm3 | 759.2 mg/cm3 (p = 0.035) |
The compression group also showed more osteoclasts, more empty lacunae, and higher expression of TNF-alpha, IL-6 and HIF-1-alpha. The authors conclude that locking fixation avoided implant-induced osteoporosis over the study period.
The sample was three dogs. That is enough to raise a biological question and not enough to settle it.
So when is locking worth the premium
The evidence supports locking fixation in four situations:
- Comminuted fractures where the construct must carry load across a gap rather than share it with cortical contact.
- Short working lengths, where screw purchase in each fragment is limited.
- Osteopenic or thin cortical bone, where conventional screws may strip or toggle.
- Small fragments and small patients, where a two-hole locking plate may be preferable to a longer non-locking construct.
Non-locking fixation remains reasonable in three situations:
- Simple diaphyseal fractures reduced with good cortical apposition, where load sharing is available.
- Young, healthy bone with good screw purchase.
- Cost-sensitive cases where the mechanical margin is not needed and the surgeon is experienced with the technique.
The caveat that rarely appears in sales material
Locking constructs do not eliminate stress shielding. The finite element discussion notes that a stiff implant absorbs load that would otherwise stimulate bone remodelling, and that high screw density near the fracture increases stress concentration at the screw-plate interface. Locking solves a stability problem; it can create a biology problem.
That is not an argument against locking plates. It is an argument against treating them as a default for every fracture.
Are locking plates stronger than non-locking plates?
In the published finite element model, the locking construct showed lower implant stress and less fragment displacement. The model confounds plate design with material, so the result supports the general direction rather than isolating the locking mechanism.
Do locking plates prevent bone loss?
A 36-week canine study found no significant bone mineral density loss with locking fixation, versus a significant loss with compression plating. The sample was three dogs, so the finding is suggestive rather than definitive.
Should every fracture be treated with a locking plate?
No. Simple fractures with good apposition and healthy bone can be treated with non-locking fixation when the surgeon is experienced and the construct shares load with cortical contact.
Is a two-hole locking plate adequate?
In the patellar fracture model, two-hole and four-hole locking plates showed no significant difference in failure load. That supports the two-hole option in small patients, within the limits of a synthetic model.
What should a buyer ask for?
Ask for the test conditions, the material of each construct, the sample size and whether the comparison was clinical or computational. Those four answers determine how much weight the claim deserves.
What we supply
Shuangyang Medical Instrument manufactures both locking and non-locking veterinary orthopaedic plates, together with screws, pins and instrument sets. Product pages state material, profile, hole configuration and available sizes. Our technical team can advise on which configuration matches a given fracture pattern, rather than defaulting every case to the higher-cost option.
References and sources
- Veterinary World (2025) — FEA of non-locking, double-rod clamp and locking constructs
- Frontiers in Veterinary Science (2025) — Patellar fracture model: wiring vs two-/four-hole locking plates
- PLOS ONE — 36-week canine radius study: locking vs compression plating bone density
Choosing locking or non-locking fixation?
Share the fracture pattern and bone quality — our technical team can advise on plate configuration, material and size, rather than defaulting every case to the higher-cost option.
Request a Quote